Whole Genome Duplications -
None in
Amborella?
Comparing molecular evolutionary rates between duplicated gene
sequences that do NOT entail changes in resulting proteins can provide
a crude measure of the age of the duplication in question. In this
example, this rate of change (Ks) was calculated for pairs of duplicated
genes from different plants. Water lily (
Nuphar) shows a pattern seen
in a number of other angiosperms: many duplicate pairs (expressed by
their frequency) with low Ks values (i.e., young age), a trailing off of
numbers of pairs with increasing Ks, followed by a 'hump' of many
duplicate pairs centering around Ks = 0.5.

The expected distribution of gene pairs given a simple process of birth
and death of duplicates is shown by the green line.

The hump of many older duplication events around K = 0.5, however, is
suggestive of a single underlying cause, i.e., a whole genome
duplication.  The expectation for such an event is shown by the fitted
black line. (The smaller hump in
Nuphar [yellow fitted line] at higher Ks
likely represents an older whole genome duplication.)

Importantly, neither
Amborella nor the gymnosperms Pinus or
Welwitschia show masses of duplicate pairs at similar age, as
represented by Ks = ca. 0.5.  In fact,
Amborella and Pinus show no
evidence whatsoever for whole genome duplication during their
evolutionary histories.
A likely inference is that a whole genome
duplication occurred along the stem lineage of all living angiosperms
clades
except Amborella.

Modified from Cui et al. (2006), based on data from Albert et al. (2005).